 Review by Dave Burrows
Introduction
We announced on 13th September 2004 that Navman have three new products coming out and subsequently on 27th September were the first to release a complete in-depth preview of the Navman iCN 510 (World Exclusive).
We now have the full production release of the Navman iCN 510 and this is the full review you have all been waiting for!
All three products comes complete with the new Navman V3 software which includes new features like:-
- Topographical maps
- Itinerary (multiple stops en-route)
- Base Roads of Europe
- Multiple Destinations (14 in total)
- Nearest POI to your location (e.g. Where's the nearest garage ?)
- Improved Next manoeuvre arrow icon with distant to move showing correct junction on roundabout to take
- Shortest Route vs Quickest Route with an Active Slider allowing you to customise how quick or show short you want the route on a sliding scale
- Active Points Of Interest
- Ability to Create, Import and Translate Custom POI's
- 2004 Map Data (Q3)
- Address to Address Postcode routing (only supporting 5 digits)
- Enhanced Route Summary
- Enhanced Zoom functionality
- Routing across rivers and inlets using shipping channels
Hardware
As many of you have been discussing in the forums and via email, the iCN 510 looks very similar in design to a Mitac DigiWalker 136, and in-fact it does advertise itself as a Mitac DigiWalker 136 when you plug it in to the PC via USB. Navman have customised the case and buttons to give it a new design. Now although the iCN 510 feels a little plasticy (just like the PiN 100), they are fairly robust. The screen is bright. Like the PiN 100, the iCN 510 has a flip-up integrated antenna but this runs SiRF XTrac 2 chipset rather than a SiRF IIe/LP chipset, so the iCN 510 is running the latest SiRF chipset (albeit pre V3 which is still not available yet in products to the consumer).
The iCN 510 comes with a PXA255 processor running at 300MHz running Windows Mobile 2003 (Windows CE.NET 4.2) and comes complete with 32mb Ram. Obviously the Navman version has been highly customised and that shows as soon as you look at the front face, the sleek design and the way the contours hold well, even the buttons look nice especially when lit in blue when pressed.
The stylus pulls out from the right hand side of the unit (when the screen is facing you), you also have a job volume control on the right hand side and a headphone jack socket.
On the back you also have a hard reset switch for the battery and on the base you have a mini USB lead and a DC power socket.
 Mounting Bracket
The mounting bracket with suction cup that comes with the iCN 510 I found really good.
The iCN 510 clips into this nicely and it's easy to remove the iCN 510 unlike the iCN630 mount which I always feel as though I'm going to break it and have to endure a tug of war session to release the iCN630 from it's tight grasp.
Some of you may think that the 510 mount because of this isn't going to be suitable, but it is, there's a distinct click noise when the 510 locks into the mount and it won't budge a millimetre!
The suction mount end terminates in a ball joint similar to the 630 so you could use a replacement 630 suction mount in the future if you wanted one in each car.
 Antenna
The iCN 510 has a built-in flip-up antenna, and also has an external antenna socket so that an external patch antenna can be connected if required.
Software
As I have already intimated, the iCN 510 comes with SmartST V3 which is a much newer version of the Navman GPS Navigation program, including newer maps and functionality.
Maps
As with SmartST V2 you can pan the map and also change the elevation view from 2D to 3D by using the up/down cursor pad. When Navman say Topographical, it's not true topographical like you would see with elevation data where the maps are in true 3D with hills looking like hills.
 
The new software basically colours the map regions better and indicates where features may be under heavy tree growth like in forests, parks etc, and also gives you lat/long grid lines on the map. You will also notice a much better horizon line with sky compared to the older version.
 
 
 
 
Next Turn Screens
You will see the Next Turn screens much better now which are accessible from pressing the page button. This not only gives you the correct turn from the roundabout or junction to take (where as before it was a generic icon), but it also shows you the turn on the map and will show your pointer when you approach it. This makes navigating some junctions a lot easier. If in doubt, hit the page button!
 
Routing Options
Routing Options is something that Navman have dramatically improved with V3 software. You now have the ability to not only select the Quickest or Shortest route, but it is provided on a sliding scale, so if you want something slightly in-between then you can adjust the slider to the position you feel more comfortable with. Navman have also made the sliding scale available for Freeway/Motorway and also Urban Roads, so you can truly customise your routing options here and make sure that you are routed by the preference you prefer.
You also have the ability to Avoid Toll Roads, Avoid Unsealed Roads and Avoid Ferries which are new features that also augment the routing algorithms, and you can toggle on and off the warnings for each of these, and select whether you want to be automatically re-routed
 
 
Warning and Language Nothing really to mention here apart from you can select from a large selection of languages and that you should not be using the cursor pad whilst driving!
 
Routing Algorithm
I have found that having the routing option set up as the default in the screen to the right, e.g. bias complete towards Quickest, Preferences for Freeways set at mid-point and Preference for Urban Roads set at Use More, this seems to give the most accurate journey for the types of journeys I have been driving.
The best thing to do is to try each setting for a few days or maybe a week and see what you think is better for the roads you prefer to travel on.
Also try driving different roads, to different destinations, do not just solely rely on your trip from home to the office each day as this may be good when set to one setting but may not be good when you set it to a different setting.
Trip Planner
Navman have now implemented a Trip Planner screen where you can add up to 14 destinations. It sorts them in the order you have added them, so if you want to optimise the route you will need to do this manually yourself. There is also a facility to MOVE the address and to manually sort them by tapping and holding an address in the Trip Planner screen and then selecting MOVE, then use the cursor pad (not touch screen) to move the address up or down.
Display Settings
You have the ability to set the display to auto-zoom when close to a junction, to Display Next Turn Screen and also to Display Next 4 Turns Screen. You can also change the Map Colour Scheme from Desert to Ocean, Snow, Salmon, and High Contrast as well as set the map colours from Day to Night and to turn on/off the Topographical Display. Navman have also give you the ability to turn the Map Grid Display on/off, the Compass on/off and No Entry Roads on/off.
POI's
You have the selection of showing POI's on the Map screen or to not show these. Categories include:- Accommodation, Amenities, Automotive Facilities, Buildings and Monuments, Entertainment, Financial Services, Food and Drink, Institutions, Medical Services, Natural Attractions, Shopping, Sports Facilities, Tourist Attractions and Transport.
Active POI's
Active POI allows you to import CSV files with details like Lat/Long and Name into the iCN 510 and this will allow you to add-on new custom POI's from PocketGPSWorld.com and also our Safety Camera Database. Unfortunately we didn't have the software available in the beta version to import this, so could not test it's functionality or accuracy. You can also set speed reminders in telling you if you are over the speed limit and also Warn driver when operating plus Warn when GPS lost.
Comparing the new iCN 510 to the Navman PiN 100
Below you will see some photos comparing the iCN 510 to the PiN 100. You can see both are approximately the same size although the iCN 510 is a little thicker and longer than the PiN.
As you can see, the same look and feel in terms of the case ergonomics have been kept between the PiN and the new iCN 510, the main difference is the PiN has a portrait look and the iCN 510 more of a landscape look.
The iCN 510 comes pre-installed ready to go and drive-away where as the PiN 100 has to be installed to like a regular Pocket PC using the supplied CD's of Western Europe.
 Problems Encountered
To start with I really liked the cursor pad. Sitting at a desk the cursor pad was real touch sensitive and made controlling the iCN 510 very easy. However, take it in-car and try to navigate with the cursor pad and you'll find once it's suctioned to the windscreen it's too sensitive. Now, bear in mind that you shouldn't be using this to enter addresses whilst driving, or to be scrolling through menus, so although it may be a problem for some, it shouldn't be for most. You can still use the touch screen rather than keypad if you want though.
I mentioned back in the preview in September that I had some issues panning between 2D and 3D mode and pressing the cursor pad (up or down) 6 or 7 times seemed to create a lag, the system slowed down and it was though the keyboard buffer was full. The production model is a little better but still suffers from this and I find it's better if you want to change from 2D to 3D then just tap and drag your finger up or down the screen and it will quickly take you in and out of 3D mode.
These are only minor niggles, there really was nothing else that caused major concern.
Adding Speed Cameras (Safety Cameras) and other Points Of Interest databases is fairly easy to install to a Navman iCN 510. You need first to have the POI file in a CSV format with no header (to the columns) and Long/Lat and the Name (in quotes). Once you have this, you are good to go.
We have thousands of POI's available on our POI-Sync service and also on the TomTom GO POI page. You can convert any of these by downloading them, using the TomTom utility called DUMPOV2 and once converted to a text or comma delimited CSV file, make sure quotes are around the names description (third column) and you should be good to go with importing into your Navman iCN 510.
Downloading the Pocket GPS Safety Camera Database
1. Download from Pocket GPS Safety Camera Database page
Extracting the Database on the PC
1. Extract the ZIP file contents to a directory on your PC, e.g. C:\temp
Preparing the database to work with Navman's software
1. Open the relevant CSV file you want to transfer, e.g. C:\temp\POCKETGPS_UK_GATSO.CSV in NOTEPAD or any text editor.
2. Delete the first line to remove the Latitude and Longitude information, so the first line reads the data (no space)
3. Save the file (FILE | SAVE)
Installing Pocket GPS Safety Camera Database
1. Run Navman SmartST Desktop on your PC.
2. Click MAP | POI's to open the POI Editor.
3. Click FILE | OPEN and point to your edited CSV file, e.g. C:\Temp\POCKETGPS_UK_GATSO.CSV
4. You should now see the Speed Camera data in a screen below.
5. Click FILE | SAVE TO DEVICE
6. Now tick ACTIVE, VISUAL ALERT, IMPERIAL, 150, Increase the POI Visibility and also point to the BMP file you extracted earlier from the ZIP file, e.g. C:\Temp\pocketgps_uk_gatso.bmp
7. Now enter a name to appear within the Navman software.
This should have now downloaded the data to your iCN or V3 software and you should now see it in there and be notified of the latest Speed Cameras.
Pro's
- Lightweight
- Slim
- Fits in your shirt pocket
- Good battery life
- Touch Screen
Con's
- Screen not as bright as iCN600 range
- Speaker not as loud as the iCN600 range (about the same loudness as most PDA's)
- Remote control is optional
- 3D mode sometimes makes it difficult to see certain roads ahead and your highlighted journey
Conclusion
The iCN 510 really is a good product. Why do I like this so much ? Well if you compare it to the nearest competitor which is TomTom GO, then it's a much slimmer product, fits in your shirt pocket and is pleasant to use. TomTom GO likewise is a great product but it's a little over-sized with it's built-in sensors, and you are sort of left wondering where to put it when you leave your car for a walk around town. Not with the iCN 510! Compare the iCN 510 with the new Garmin Quest, and although the Quest is smaller in size, even better for the shirt pocket, there's a huge compromise on the size of the screen. That's 3.5" for the iCN 510 compared with 2.2" for the Garmin Quest. You can sort of see where I'm coming from here. The iCN 510 gives you everything you want without sacrificing the size of the screen.
Overall the iCN 510 is a great product, it's like a PDA because it runs the latest Windows Mobile 2003 Operating System (CE 4.2) but it's not because you cannot get to the operating system and you don't have any PDA functions available to you, if you hard reset it, the V3 software will re-run itself. It's an entry level iCN and one I think will fit good into the Navman iCN range, especially with the new features like Topographical style maps, Active POI's, this really does enhance upon Navman's current software version.
|
