Strange local route

[cottonsocks]

OK, I don't know whether this is going to work, but I'm going to have my first attempt at including an image in my posting.

If this works, it will show two slightly different short routes, each from the same start to the same destination. My query is, why would the Garmin device send me along the magenta route, when the actual route I always use (in green) is about 25% shorter and (according to Garmin) the same distance? Note in case you're wondering, I don't use the sat nav just for this route, but it's often the first little tiny part of my overall routes to North Worcestershire and my sat nav always tries to take me on this little detour.[img]https://app.box.com/s/xplxwo5ga1ks61nkq6far0gkmr6er529[/img]

Hmm - the preview doesn't show the image in the post, so I'm not sure how this works.

[M8TJT]

The link you are trying to link to does though. Copy/paste int browser

[Kremmen]

That would work if it linked to Imgur
_________________
Satnav:
Garmin 2599 LMT-D (Indoor test rig)
DashCam:
Viofo A119 V3
Car Average MPG :

[M8TJT]

using img /img doesnt seem to work for me either
but url= /url does.
here

[cwog]

Perhaps the Garmin does not like you taking right turns onto roads, The Garmin route is all left turns, so theoretically easier.

[walkerx]

i have a similar problem everyday - the device has realised where i am going and plans a route to it - i come of the same junction every day as the route the garmin takes me, is usually into queuing traffic and even without this, it is no faster than the route i go.

the mytrends shows the route i take all the time and this is the same when leaving work for home, yet for some reason it never picks the routes i actually go.

my go5000 on the other hand picks the correct junction so not sure why the garmin can't

[CDK]

cottonsocks:
[My First Thought - Before Edit]
It is possible the Garmin is routing via the more 'senior' B4638 road which the unit might deem to be faster and less congested, rather than the smaller Millwood Drive.
Might it also depend on the Faster/Shorter/etc Routing setting...?

[EDIT]
HOWEVER just did a quick test on Mapsource on my PC:

Routing from 'Lyppard Bourne' to 'Parson' as on your map, it indeed routes as you have shown in magenta.

If you INVERT the route going backwards from 'Parson' to 'Lyppard Bourne' shown in your map, it does actually route you down your preferred green route via Plantation Drive & Millwood Drive. So it does work backwards; ie on the return route.

Again, starting from Lyppard Bourne, it does not seem to mind if you manually change the route to force it to go up Millwood Drive which probably means there no one way or other restrictions in its database.

Changing the Faster/Shorter settings or type of vehicle also seems to make no difference.

So there is something in its calculation algorithm system that forces it to route outwards via the south bound B4638 - but not the north bound B4638.

Ofcourse my exercise is on a stand alone Mapsource on my PC.
The other consideration is that if you are routing on your unit, it might be taking the time of day and traffic conditions into account and routing you out onto the faster less congested route.

cwog
Just some Off Topic info in the 'Useless Info' Category:
J Edgar Hoover of FBI fame, had a standing instruction to his driver NEVER to make a left turn.
As in: His theory, Left = Commies !

Sorry it is a bit late !!

We see you’re using an ad-blocker. We’re fine with that and won’t stop you visiting the site.
Have you considered making a donation towards website running costs?.
Or you could disable your ad-blocker for this site. We think you’ll find our adverts are not overbearing!